As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
Quick Answer:
- This fir with 800 warm white LEDs and PE tips is the best overall alternative to the Balsam Hill BH Fraser Fir.
- This 60-inch fir with 5,773 tips and one-plug setup is the fullest tree with one-plug setup.
- This 65-inch fir with 1,000 clear lights is the best pick for classic clear lights.
- This 60-inch fir with 800 warm lights is the best value for the full Balsam Hill size.
There is a moment every December when the lights go on for the first time and the whole room changes. Many people buy a Balsam Hill tree to get that moment right: the 7.5-foot BH Fraser Fir is full and symmetrical, about five feet wide, with more than 3,200 lifelike tips and 800 clear lights, and it costs about $949. These Amazon trees match its size, fullness and glow, so you can have that same first-night feeling for a fraction of the price.
| Alternative | Price | Size | Tips | Lights |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Puleo Balsam FirShop on Amazon | $357.73 | 7.5 ft tall, 60 in wide | 4,703 PE and PVC | 800 warm white LED |
| Hykolity PremiumShop on Amazon | $449.98 | 7.5 ft tall, 60 in wide | 5,773 PE and PVC | 1,050 warm white and multicolor LED |
| National Tree Company Fraser GrandeShop on Amazon | $359.92 | 7.5 ft tall, 65 in wide | 3,719 Feel Real | 1,000 clear |
| Naomi Home 7.5 ftShop on Amazon | $244.99 | 7.5 ft tall, 60 in wide | 3,661 | 800 warm incandescent |
| Best Choice Products Full AspenShop on Amazon | $349.99 | 7.5 ft tall, 58 in wide | 3,000 PE and PVC | 1,500 micro LED, white and multicolor |
| Glitzhome Majestic Evergreen FirShop on Amazon | $299.98 | 7.5 ft tall, 56 in wide | 3,261 (2,151 PE) | 1,800 warm white and multicolor |
Amazon prices and availability shown are as of Nov 3, 11:21 PM ET, or the last recorded check for a listing Amazon is not currently pricing, and can change; the price on Amazon at checkout applies.
The Original
Balsam Hill's full, true-to-life Fraser fir.
The BH Fraser Fir is modeled on the Southern Fraser fir, the tree many families once drove out to a farm to cut. The 7.5-foot version is 58 inches wide with more than 3,272 tips, molded PE needles blended with classic PVC for fullness, 800 clear LED lights and Easy Plug, which runs the power through the trunk so there is one cord to plug in. Its dark green tips show silvery undersides, just like the real thing.
The Alternatives
Full 7.5-foot firs with the Balsam Hill size, fullness and glow.
Puleo International 7.5 Foot Pre-Lit Balsam Fir with 800 Warm White LED Lights
The Puleo Balsam Fir is the tree we would bring home in place of the BH Fraser Fir. Picture it in the corner by the fireplace on the first cold night of December: 800 warm white LEDs, the same count as the Balsam Hill, hand-strung so the glow spreads evenly from the top branch to the bottom, and the bulbs stay lit even if one goes out. It is built the way Balsam Hill builds its trees, with molded, crush-resistant PE tips on the outside and PVC tips inside for depth, and it has more of them, 4,703 in all, on a full 60-inch base with plenty of room for the ornaments your kids made in kindergarten. Hinged branches and letter-coded sections make the yearly setup quick, and it is backed by a five-year tree warranty and a two-year light warranty. Puleo International is America's oldest Christmas tree brand, a fourth-generation family company with more than 70 years of trees behind it, and this one costs well under half as much as the Balsam Hill.
Shop the Puleo Balsam FirFull Firs With 800 or More White Lights
The warm, classic glow of a traditional Christmas tree.
Hykolity 7.5ft Premium Prelit Christmas Tree, 5,773 Realistic Tips, Fast Connect, 1,050 Dual Color LEDs
With 5,773 PE and PVC tips on a 60-inch base, the Hykolity Premium is so thick that your ornaments nestle into the branches instead of hanging in open air, the way they do on a fresh-cut tree. Fast Connect powers the sections through the trunk, so the whole tree lights with one plug, and its 1,050 LEDs glow warm white or switch to multicolor for Christmas Eve, with a remote, a foot pedal and a timer that turns it on before you get home.
Best For
A big family room where the tree is the heart of every holiday photo.
Pairs Well With
A woven tree collar, red and gold glass ornaments and a plaid ribbon garland.
National Tree Company 7.5ft Pre-Lit Fraser Grande with 1,000 Clear Lights
The Fraser Grande has the crisp, classic sparkle of clear lights, 1,000 of them, the look of a department store window when you were small. Its 3,719 Feel Real tips spread across a generous 65-inch base, so it fills a two-story foyer or a wide living room the way a grand tree should, and the lights stay on even if a bulb goes out.
Best For
A tall foyer or large living room that wants a tree with presence.
Pairs Well With
Oversized velvet bows, a galvanized tree collar and a long boxwood garland on the stairs.
Naomi Home 7.5ft Artificial Prelit Rustic Christmas Tree with 800 Warm Lights
The Naomi Home has the soft golden glow of the incandescent bulbs on your grandparents' tree, 800 of them, across 3,661 deep green tips on a full 60-inch base. It matches the Balsam Hill in size and light count for about a quarter of the price, which leaves room in the budget for the gifts underneath.
Best For
A classic, cozy tree at the lowest price here.
Pairs Well With
Brass bells, dried orange garland and a vintage quilt as a tree skirt.
Full Firs That Also Switch to Color
Warm white for quiet nights, color for Christmas morning.
Best Choice Products Full Aspen Christmas Tree, 7.5ft Pre-Lit Noble Fir with 1,500 Twinkling Micro LEDs
Best Choice Products covers its noble fir in 1,500 tiny micro LEDs, so the tree shimmers like frost catching candlelight. It glows warm white most nights and switches to multicolor when the kids want the tree of their childhood, all on the same 58-inch width as the BH Fraser Fir with 3,000 PE and PVC tips. The cordless sections power up as you stack them, so you plug in once and get straight to the ornaments.
Best For
Families who want warm white for grown-up evenings and color for Christmas morning.
Pairs Well With
A woven tree collar, wood bead garland and handmade ornaments.
Glitzhome 7.5ft Pre-Lit Majestic Evergreen Fir with 1,800 Warm White and Multi-Color Lights
The Majestic Evergreen Fir glows from tip to trunk with 1,800 lights, more than twice the BH Fraser Fir's, in warm white or multicolor with gentle chasing and twinkling effects for the night you gather everyone around it. Its 3,261 tips are mostly molded PE, 2,151 of them, on a 56-inch base close to the Balsam Hill's width.
Best For
A tree that feels like the main event at every holiday party.
Pairs Well With
Red and green glass ornaments, a red velvet tree skirt and a gold star.
Balsam Hill BH Fraser Fir vs. the Amazon Alternatives
All six are 7.5-foot firs about five feet wide with thousands of tips and 800 or more lights, the same size and glow that make the Balsam Hill feel like Christmas. The light color and setup decide which one belongs in your home.
Balsam Hill BH Fraser Fir vs. Puleo Balsam Fir: which wins in 2026?
Choose the Puleo for the same 800 LEDs and the same PE-over-PVC build for well under half the price. Both are full 7.5-foot trees about five feet wide with molded PE tips outside and PVC inside. The Puleo has more tips, 4,703 to 3,272, and its warm white LEDs give the cozy, candlelit glow of an old-fashioned tree, where the Balsam Hill's clear lights read crisper. It comes with a five-year tree warranty and a two-year light warranty.
Balsam Hill BH Fraser Fir vs. Hykolity Premium: which wins in 2026?
Choose the Hykolity Premium for the most tips and one-plug setup. It has 5,773 PE and PVC tips on a 60-inch base, so the branches look as thick as a fresh-cut tree, plus Fast Connect sections that power up through the trunk and 1,050 LEDs that also switch to multicolor.
Balsam Hill BH Fraser Fir vs. National Tree Company Fraser Grande: which wins in 2026?
Choose the Fraser Grande for classic clear lights and extra fullness. It has 1,000 clear lights and 3,719 Feel Real tips on a 65-inch base, a little wider than the BH Fraser Fir, which gives a big room the grand tree it deserves.
Balsam Hill BH Fraser Fir vs. Naomi Home 7.5 ft: which wins in 2026?
Choose the Naomi Home for the full size and light count at the lowest price. It has 800 warm incandescent lights and 3,661 tips on a 60-inch base for about a quarter of the price, with the soft golden glow of a classic family tree.
Balsam Hill BH Fraser Fir vs. Best Choice Products Full Aspen: which wins in 2026?
Choose the Best Choice Products tree for one-plug setup and a multicolor option. It is the same 58-inch width with 3,000 PE and PVC tips and 1,500 shimmering micro LEDs, and its cordless sections power up as you stack them.
Balsam Hill BH Fraser Fir vs. Glitzhome Majestic Evergreen Fir: which wins in 2026?
Choose the Glitzhome for the most lights. It has 1,800 warm white and multicolor lights with chasing and twinkle effects and 3,261 mostly PE tips on a 56-inch base.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the best alternative to a Balsam Hill Christmas tree?+
How much does the Balsam Hill BH Fraser Fir cost?+
Which alternative has the same light count as Balsam Hill?+
Do any of these trees plug in once like Balsam Hill's Easy Plug?+
Which alternative has PE tips like Balsam Hill?+
Which tree is the fullest?+
The Verdict
The Puleo International Balsam Fir is our pick for the Balsam Hill look: the same 800 LEDs and PE-over-PVC build on 4,703 tips and a full 60-inch base, glowing warm white like the trees you remember, for well under half the price. For the fullest branches and one-plug setup, choose the Hykolity Premium; for classic clear lights, the National Tree Company Fraser Grande; for the lowest price, the Naomi Home.
The Best Choice Products Full Aspen adds shimmering micro lights and a multicolor setting, and the Glitzhome Majestic Evergreen Fir has the most lights of all.
Dreaming of a white Christmas instead? Our King of Christmas flocked tree alternatives cover full snow-flocked trees, and our Grand Duchess Christmas tree alternatives compare trees covered in thousands of color-changing lights.
Keep Shopping
More Rugs & Decor We Love
Traditional · Christmas Trees
Best King of Christmas King Flock Alternatives of 2026: 5 Snow-Flocked 7.5-Foot Trees on Amazon
6 min read
Traditional · Christmas Trees
Best Grand Duchess Christmas Tree Alternatives of 2026: 5 Viral-Style 7.5-Foot Trees With Thousands of Color-Changing Lights
6 min read
.jpg?w=1200)
Traditional · Lighting
Tiffany Lamp Alternatives: 5 Amazon Stained-Glass Picks (2026)
6 min read
Splurge vs Save · Lighting
Best Arco Lamp Alternatives of 2026: 5 Arc Floor Lamp Picks from Teamson Home, Major-Q, and Brightech
10 min read
Splurge vs Save · Mirrors
Anthropologie Primrose Mirror Alternatives: 6 Gilded Picks (2026)
9 min read
Eclectic · Trending
3 Best Mushroom Lamps for a Cozy Bedroom (2026)
7 min read